Consider a sphere of radius R with charge density distributed as ρρ(r)=kr for r≤R=0r≤R=0for r>R.
(a) Find the electric field at all points r.
(b) Suppose the total charge on the sphere is 2e where e is the electron charge. Where can two protons be embedded such that the force on each of them is zero? Assume that the introduction of the proton does not alter the negative charge distribution.
Hint: Use Gauss' law.
(a) Step 1: Find the electric field for r<R.
Let us consider a sphere S of radius R and two hypothetic spheres of radius r<R and r>R.
Now, for point r<R, electric field intensity will be given by,
∮E.dS=1ε0∫ρdV [For dV, V=43πr3⇒dV=3×43πr2dr=4πr2dr]∮E.dS=1ε0∫ρdV [For dV, V=43πr3⇒dV=3×43πr2dr=4πr2dr]
⇒∮E.dS=1ε04πK∫r0r3dr (∵ρ(r)=Kr)⇒∮E.dS=1ε04πK∫r0r3dr (∵ρ(r)=Kr)
⇒(E) 4πr2=4πKε0r44⇒(E) 4πr2=4πKε0r44
⇒E=14ε0Kr2⇒E=14ε0Kr2
Here, the charge density is positive.
So, the direction of E is radially outwards.
Step 2: Find the electric field for r>R.
For points r>H, electric field intensity will be given by,
∮E.dS=1ε0∫ρdV∮E.dS=1ε0∫ρdV
⇒E(4πr2)=4πKε0∫R0r3dr=4πKε0R44⇒E(4πr2)=4πKε0∫R0r3dr=4πKε0R44
⇒E=K4ε0R4r2⇒E=K4ε0R4r2
Th charge density is again positive. So, the direction of E is radially outward.
(b) Step 3: Identify the location of the protons.
The two protons must be on the opposite sides of the centre along a diameter following the rule of symmetry. This can be shown by the figure given below. Charge on the sphere,
Step 4: Find the net force on the protons.
q=∫R0ρdV=∫R0(Kr)4πr2drq=∫R0ρdV=∫R0(Kr)4πr2dr
q=4πKR44=2eq=4πKR44=2e
∴K=2eπR4∴K=2eπR4
If protons 1 and 2 are embedded at distance r from the centre of the sphere as shown, then attractive force on proton 1 due to charge distribution is:
F1=eE=-eKr24ε0F1=eE=−eKr24ε0
Repulsive force on proton 1 due to proton 2 is:
F2=e24πε0(2r)2F2=e24πε0(2r)2
The net force on proton 1,
F=F1+F2F=F1+F2
F=-eKr24ε0+e216πε0r2F=−eKr24ε0+e216πε0r2
So, F=[-er24ε0ZeπR4+e216πε0r4]F=[−er24ε0ZeπR4+e216πε0r4]
Step 5: Find the distance between the protons.
Thus, the net force on proton 1 will be zero, when:
er22e4ε0πR4=e216πε0rer22e4ε0πR4=e216πε0r
⇒r4=R48⇒r4=R48
⇒r=R(8)1/4⇒r=R(8)1/4
This is the distance of each of the two protons from the centre of the sphere.